Exhibiting Craft: Histories, contexts, practices
Claire Jones, Department of Art History, Curating and Visual Studies, University of Birmingham, email@example.com
Inês Jorge, Department of Art History, Curating and Visual Studies, University of Birmingham, firstname.lastname@example.org
Craft has mainly been defined in relation – and in opposition – to fine art, design and industry; practices of making; and national, disciplinary and material boundaries. The emerging field of exhibition histories offers a significant framework for understanding how craft has been shaped by different contexts and methods of display. The wide scope of spaces, agents, strategies and practices involved in craft exhibitions suggests that these can be powerful tools for asserting and questioning the creative,political, economic, institutional and social role of craft, and for engaging with various publics.
This session will explore craft from the perspective of exhibition and display histories.
Speakers & Abstracts
Between craft, art design
Exhibiting Greek Embroidery in Britain during the Second World War
Lenia Kouneni (University of St Andrews)
This paper will discuss the display of Greek embroidery in a series of temporary wartime exhibitions entitled Greek Art 3000 B.C. - A.D 1938 organised in Britain during the Second World War. It will analyse the scope of the organisers, the display of the artworks, and their reception by the public. It will argue that the inclusion of Greek embroidery contributed significantly to the main aim of these exhibitions: the demonstration of the continuity of Greek art. In these displays, embroideries helped to create a narrative that emphasised the links between the past and present in a turbulent period. Their display and interpretation also emphasised the role of women as the keepers of tradition. This paper will argue that the inclusion of embroidery and its juxtaposition to ‘high’ classical Greek art in this series of exhibitions was instrumental in highlighting the continuity of design and artistic tradition, and demonstrating the resilience of Greek identity and heritage. By doing so, it also challenged the male-dominated fields of ancient Greek painting and sculpture, and positioned female craftsmanship at the centre of the discourse on cultural continuity. The assertions made were particularly important in the context of the Second World War and the German occupation of Greece. As the exhibitions were co-sponsored by the Greek government-in-exile and the British Council, they were used as propaganda and as a morale booster for the wartime British public.
Ann Coxon (Curator, International Art, Tate Modern)
A number of recent exhibitions have looked back to textile-based art practice, ‘fibre art’ or soft art from the 1960s and 1970s, in an attempt to rediscover and redefine bodies of work using fibre, thread or rope, many of which have not been included in canonical accounts of 20th century art history. Examples include the exhibition Fiber Sculpture: 1960 – present at the ICA Boston, 2014; Art & Textiles, at the Kunstmuseum Wolsburg, 2014; and Textiles: Open Letter at the Museum Abteiberg, Mönchengladbach in 2013. In addition, publications such as String, Felt, Thread: The Hierarchy of Art and Craft in American Art, 2009 by Elissa Auther or Fray: Art and Textile Politics, 2018 by Julia Bryan Wilson have considered the territory of textile art and craft practices in the US. At the Tate Modern, textile works from the 1960s by Lenore Tawney, Sheila Hicks and Olga de Amaral have been acquired in the past decade and were brought together in the display titled Beyond Craft, 2017–18, and within the major retrospective exhibition Anni Albers, 2018–19. Despite this, and despite historical attempts to establish the importance of ‘Fiber Art’ in the US, or the significance of the radically expanded forms of tapestry at the international Lausanne Tapestry Biennial in the 1960s, these bodies of work remain under-researched and under-represented within academic and museum contexts. My paper will consider some of these recent exhibitions, raising questions about art–craft hierarchies, medium specificity, canonical expansion and the future for textile-based practice within the art museum.
Practices of making
Displaying technical gestures on craft-related exhibitions
Inés Moreno (École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales)
Seeking to reflect on the regimes of visibility of technical gesture as defined by the framework of anthropology of technology, in an attempt to grasp what occurs between a body, a tool and a material in a context of specific social and cultural production, I will propose to analyse three recent exhibitions shown in French institutions in order to identify different curatorial discourses and museographic practices. The focus will be to explore the potential of the exhibition device for enhancing technical awareness and making visible the entanglements between material culture and gestural knowledge, of which it is the product. The analysis of the ethnography-based curatorial project Meilleurs Ouvriers de France at the Musée des Arts et Métiers (2017), the group show The mind begins and ends in the fingertips (2019) at Palais de Tokyo, and the two-fold exhibition La Beauté du Geste (The Beauty of the gesture) (2019/20) at the City of Ceramics in Sèvres will shed light on the possibilities and pitfalls of displaying know-how and tacit skills. These exhibitions, which took place in different institutional settings (a technical museum, a contemporary art site, and a national museum associated with a porcelain factory), even if they share certain common questioning, convey a set of divergent lines of discourse that will be linked to several museographic traditions. applying some notional and methodological tools of the anthropology of technology such as that of the ‘operational sequence’, the aim will be to interrogate the role of exhibitions in unveiling the complex set of actions, both material and intellectual, involved in the making of things, and in highlighting the know-how inscribed in the objects.
Within and beyond the museum
‘Shifting Ground’: The Glasgow Society of Lady Artists and altering Glasgow’s exhibition culture
Karen Mailley-Watt (The University of Glasgow and The Glasgow School of Art)
Imogen Hart (University of California, Berkeley)
For craft societies in interwar Britain, exhibitions served the purposes of exposure, promotion, critique and community-building. In the various experimental forms they took, exhibitions were not only the spaces in which makers reached markets, but also sites in which urgent debates about the function and morality of craft, the communities it served, and its value in the modern world could be played out. Examining and comparing the practices of the Red Rose Guild (Manchester)and the Little Gallery (London), this paper explores how these groups used exhibitions in different ways to shape their identities as craft organisations and to engage with local, regional, national and international audiences. Craftspeople and curators, many of them women, developed exhibiting strategies that made visible the conditions of production, embraced the functional characteristics of objects, and evoked the bodies and rituals of domestic space. By foregrounding considerations of labour and use, craft exhibitions encouraged particular kinds of engagement with the objects they displayed. Drawing on feminist and everyday life theory, the paper considers the radical potential of such practices. Presenting new research gathered from archival materials and published reviews, the paper reconstructs exhibitions mounted by these groups in the 1920s and 1930s, analysing key displays and the rhetoric that framed them in order to illuminate the ways in which craft objects were put into conversation with one another and mobilised to support various artistic, social and political agendas.
Craft as Contemporary: The Museo del Barrio in Asunción
Sofia Gotti (University of Cambridge)
Since the 1980s, it has been a priority for Paraguayan scholars to question and remap the canonical division of craft and art. Thinker and critic Ticio Escobar, alongside prominent historical figures in Paraguay such as Olga Blinder, Carlos Colombino and Osvaldo Salerno, have worked tirelessly to institutionalise indigenous art on a par with what Escobar terms erudite art and the critical-illustrated tradition. The impressive Museo del Barro in Asunción holds an extensive collection of art dating from the pre-colonial period to the present day, and mounts cyclical contemporary art exhibitions. From its inception, the museum strives to challenge and reconfigure the dynamics that determine the categorisation and valuation of art. The collection straddles art and craft, and it engages with non-mainstream systems through which popular art and indigenous art circulated, breaking with hegemonic cultural hierarchies. Such efforts are rooted in Paraguay’s longstanding engagement in public policy around the question of indigeneity. In this paper, I will examine how the display and exhibition practice at the museum has treated the display of objects in ways that erode the difference between art and craft. Looking at a permanent display room, I will examine the curatorial strategies that make the viewer reflexive of the different notions of non-linear time that indigenous populations share. By examining a recent temporary exhibition featuring indigenous contemporary art, I will examine how the museum is resisting the homogenisation of indigenous culture, fostered by nationalist narratives rooted in the false nationalist myth of a shared Guaraní race in Paraguay.